Genre Choice

Leather boots

Being asked by a friend who only reads true literary fiction what I am writing used to feel like a pop quiz I was sure to fail. “Hi, my name is Justine and my current works in progress contain a computer virus alien race, a divorcee with an imaginary friend, and superheroes who fight monsters that come through inter-dimensional rifts. Please do not throw tomatoes or insults at me.” I would say it with shyness, with shame, as though what I was writing was any less valid than your normal everyday literary work. There’s literary fiction and there’s commercial fiction, and my muse just happens to like superheroes who fight monsters that come through inter-dimensional rifts.  So sue me.

But the truth is, this is where the muse takes me. It takes me to weird stuff, and, in this case it takes me to fantasy. When I came up with the idea for The Order of the Key, it only made sense that the main character, Jacklyn, would be young. She couldn’t be too young, for reasons I can’t really express without spoiling the plot for Book 1, but she had to be in that stage where she was figuring out who she was as a person. Initially, because some of the themes could run a little dark, I attempted to write Jacklyn as an adult, but it didn’t track well. The voice Jacklyn had placed in my head was plucky, young, and irreverent.

There was also a very specific theme that I wanted to explore, and that was this idea of dreams vs. reality. Jacklyn has this love for comic books, superheroes, and all things geeky. So, at first, when she is pulled into this world where she is the superhero, it seems like a dream come true, even if the circumstances surrounding it aren’t the best. But, as she struggles with the responsibilities of actually living that dream (risking those around her, putting herself on the line, being forced to do things she wouldn’t otherwise enjoy doing), she grows to understand that there is a big difference between imagining a situation and enduring it. And I think this is a hard won lesson for many—this idea that we’re going to grow up to be something amazing, just to have that amazing thing turn out to be…not so amazing. And it was important to tell that story in a YA framework, because I feel like that is a lesson worth teaching to kids who are about to head into college and out into the real world—to feel free to dream, but to inject a little practicality into it. Dream big, but dream smart.

In the end, I didn’t so much choose my genre as my genre chose me. What genres do you guys write? Read? Tell me a little about why in the comments!

5 thoughts on “Genre Choice

  1. I write mostly fantasy and mostly YA. The YA is for reasons similar to yours: I really like to write about girls who are curious about the world and still trying to figure things out. Plus I remember how strongly we feel at that age, and all that emotion is fun to play around with when you write. As for the fantasy, I love to read it. I love mythology and fairy tale and I can play around with the tropes of the genre. Plus it’s fun to world build and give your characters awesome or horrific powers.

    1. You are so correct about the way emotions are heightened at that age. And I feel like with YA Fantasy, it almost becomes your duty to play around with powers and fantastical worlds as metaphors for all of the crazy things that happen when you transition from teenager to adult.

  2. I kind of identify with the start of your post, where answering the genre question feels a bit awkward and “wrong.” But although my favorite genre to read is a mystery, I’ve never attempted to write one. And even in my mysteries I like romance, even if it’s a very minor backstory. The truth is I’m a big fat sap. And I write romance. Not even the steamy erotica stuff that makes millions–just work through “stuff” to a happy ending romance.

    (I would really love to write a cracking mystery someday, but thus far the muse has not cooperated in that endeavor).

    1. I love romance! I can’t seem to write anything without one at the core of the story. And I sort of grimace through it, because I never thought I’d write romance, but there it is. So I totally identify. I’m a bit sap, too. 🙂

  3. Pingback: In a World… | Written Infinities

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s