Genre’s Bum Rap

Fairy with blonde hair, praying

Allow me to set the stage for you.  Christmas time.  I’m unwrapping a gift from my brother and his wife.  It’s a book!  Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn.  I’m happy.  I’ve wanted to read this one for a while. And then Jon says, “Yeah, I got it because I figured it was time for you to take a break from all that sci-fi crap you read.”  Am I mad at him?  No.  It’s a brother’s job to poke fun at his little sister.  Not even a job, but a sacred duty.  And I won’t even point out that he loves “The Vampire Diaries” (I have a similar duty unto him) or that he chose Gone Girl  (which was an incredible novel that I recommend) from my wishlist which means I obviously read more than just “that sci-fi crap”.  But the comment does point to another more real problem that needs addressing.

What is really wrong with reading genre work, anyway?  Nothing.

Yes, romance, science fiction, fantasy, mystery, horror, etc. novels can be formulaic and cheesy, but then, isn’t that true for any kind of art when it’s done wrong?

A good romance novel pulls you along on what you already pretty much know will be a road to a happy ending and still manages to surprise you.  A good science fiction novel has a strong message about technology, the future, the other.  Fantasy, when done correctly, can deal with the meaning and implications of power.  A good horror novel can keep you jumping.  A good mystery or suspense novel still throws you for a loop no matter how many novels of its type you’ve read.

So what separates the good from the bad?

– Strong Characters.  A character with an interesting motivation.  Someone we want to follow, maybe not in a traditional way, but we have to root for them or against them with a force created by our love or hate for them.  Ho hum characters, formulaic characters just won’t do.  Plot is what draws people into a story – characters are what keep them there.

– An interesting plot.  You can have the best characters ever, but if all they do is sit and knit all day (no offense to all you knitters out there!) nobody is going to read past the first chapter. For a genre story to be good it has to have something interesting about it that makes the tale unique.  Without that, the story just becomes another one of those formula genre novels.  There is fun to be had in those as well, but if you’re looking to stand out or blaze your own trail, you need a good hook.

– A theme.  You need to have something to say and you have to want to say it loud.  Look at The Hunger Games and what it says about entertainment and excess.  Look at the Chaos Walking series (if you haven’t read this one, do it NOW) or Ender’s Game and what they say about the nature of war.  What Divergent says about the parts of us that come together to make us whole.  What the Otherworld series says about the deeper parts of our nature. I, Robot about the dangers of technology.  Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? about the nature of humanity. Gone Girl has a lot to say about the pitfalls of marrying someone we only think we know and the ways people change under duress. They are great because they have something to say.  They weren’t merely created to fit a preordained mold.

And sometimes genre is more interesting, at least to me, for much more juvenile reasons.  Robots and monsters and cool gadgets and magic and sex and murder and badassness…and that’s kind of a fun thing to tap into.

I would like to wrap this blog up with one of the most ridiculous arguments I’ve heard against science fiction and fantasy – which is that they aren’t real.  They could never happen.  And that makes me wonder what that person is even reading fiction for?  In that case, they would probably better enjoy a biography.  Those are interesting, too, but they aren’t escapism.

For that?  Well, I’ll go back to reading my science fiction book right now.

What are your thoughts on this?  Let’s chat in the comments section below.

15 thoughts on “Genre’s Bum Rap

  1. I agree — genre is fun. I used to resist because I thought it was formulaic and corny, but I kept chatting with well-read readers and writers who kept referencing books that I was avoiding. I opened my mind and am glad I did. I’ll have to check out the Chaos Walking series. Great post — and I thoroughly enjoyed Gone Girl, too.

    1. There is plenty that can be formulaic and corny. I used to have some trouble admitting to the romance aspects of my novels because I felt like to many people, romance = cheesy bodice rippers with Fabio on the cover.

      My logic is, if you think that the idea you are dreaming up falls into a genre you find corny – how can you make your story not corny? Hopefully, that will work for me.

      The first book of the Chaos Walking Trilogy is called The Knife of Never Letting Go. It’s by Patrick Ness. You will not be disappointed.

      Thank you for stopping by! 🙂

  2. As someone who loves to read science fiction, I have to say that I am not exactly a genre reader. I actually don’t agree with sticking to one genre, but believe in expanding one’s tastes to include other genre. Thus, I read a science fiction novel, then read a biography, then a mystery, come back to sci-fi, check out a romance, read a bit of comedy, a bit of horror, come back to sci-fi and then a bit of fantasy. I find that if you only read sci-fi, you’re missing out on so many authors out there and so much interesting work. Sticking to one genre may fulfill a craving, but are you really a well-rounded reader?

    1. I agree. My point was more not to rule anything out. Much like my logic on food, I’m a firm believer in getting a little taste of everything. My guilty pleasure? Pasta and hamburgers. To me, that’s sci-fi and fantasy. I eat many different things, but I tend more towards pasta and hamburgers. Still, I’ll try anything at least once. And on the plus side, trying a different book genre won’t make you break out in hives like that one time…with the shrimp… :p

  3. There always comes a point when you realize a relationship isn’t working out (I swear this is related). For my last one, it came while we were waiting for a train together. I don’t remember exactly how we got on the topic–I brought up a Fantasy novel that I really liked and she rolled her eyes, saying her brother also liked that one and tried to get her to read it. The rest went something like this:

    Me: “Well, he’s right. You should give it a shot. It’s a great novel.”

    Her: “Please. I don’t read that shit.”

    Me: “Huh. Wow. ‘That shit,’ huh? You mean the shit I intend to do for the rest of my life?”

    Her: “… Uh…”

    Me: “I mean, you don’t have to love it, but it sounds like I spend all of my time writing absolute garbage in your eyes.”

    I believe I was going to continue into, “… Why are we actually dating?” but she parried with an, “I’m sorry,” that led into, “I should try it.” I gave her Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss and it was nice to see her admit that it was really good. And, considering that she was a both Jersey party girl and professional business woman at the same time, I’d like to think that means no one has any excuse to prematurely judge genre fiction.

  4. Pingback: Reading List of 2014 | Pieces of the Puzzle

Leave a Reply to justinemanzano Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s